Remake vs Remaster: Which is Better?

In an era where video games are constantly evolving, the terms “remake” and “remaster” often spark debate among gamers. As more and more developers reimagine classic games, understanding the differences between the two approaches can help gamers decide which games to invest their time and money in.

Definition of Remake and Remaster

What is a Remake?

A remake is when a game is remade from scratch. This process usually involves major updates to the graphics, gameplay mechanics, and even the storyline. The goal is to provide a new experience while still maintaining the essence of the original game.

For example, a popular remake of a classic game is “Triple Diamond,” developed by IGT. The original “Double Diamond” was released in 1989 and became one of the most iconic games in the industry. More than 20 years later, IGT released the modernized sequel “Triple Diamond,” which became very popular for its nostalgic yet modern style and gameplay. The game has received a lot of praise.

In video games, “Resident Evil 2 (2019)” is a prime example, transforming the 1998 classic into a modern masterpiece, featuring new and improved graphics, updated controls, and a storyline that enhances the horror elements of the original.

What is Remaster?

On the other hand, remasters focus on improving the visuals, sound, and performance of an existing game without changing the main gameplay or story. A prime example is “The Last of Us Remastered.” This game improves the graphics and refines the gameplay of the 2013 original, while keeping the story and mechanics intact.

Key Differences

Understanding the difference between a remake and a remaster can have a big impact on your game choices. Below is a simple comparison table:

Feature	Remakes	Remaster
Development	Building from scratch with new assets	Leverage existing assets to improve
The Gameplay	Mechanics or story may change	The core gameplay remains unchanged
Visual	Major graphical overhaul	Improved resolution and effects
Cost and time	It takes a lot of resources and time to make it.	Faster production at lower costs

Remakes and remasters both breathe new life into old games, but their approaches are fundamentally different.

Important Examples

A Successful Remake

Several remakes have been praised by critics and fans for their innovation while still respecting the original film:

• Resident Evil 2 (2019): This remake not only updates the graphics, but also introduces new gameplay mechanics to keep players engaged. Thanks to reconfigured camera angles and improved AI, the game feels like a completely new experience, yet still maintains the tension of the original.
• Final Fantasy VII Remake (2020): A massive expansion of the popular RPG released in 1997. The game introduces real-time combat instead of turn-based combat to provide more dynamic gameplay, and enriches the story with character development.

A Successful Remaster

On the other hand, many remasters have managed to breathe new life into classic games by improving their presentation:

• The Last of Us Remastered (2014) : This release improves the graphical quality and includes all downloadable content (DLC), making it a great entry point for new players and an enhanced experience for long-time fans.
• Bioshock: The Collection (2016): This remaster combines three Bioshock games into one, enhancing the graphics and performance, so players can revisit Rapture and Columbia in vivid detail.

Player Preferences

The choice between a remake and a remaster is largely a matter of personal preference. Some players may prefer a remake that offers a refined gameplay experience with new mechanics and narrative. Others may prefer a remaster that provides a nostalgic experience without significantly changing the original gameplay.

Gamers who value innovation in particular may be drawn to remakes that push boundaries and explore new ways of storytelling. Conversely, many prefer remasters that retain classic gameplay while offering modern enhancements.

Industry Trends

The trend towards remakes and remasters reflects an overall trend in the games industry. As development costs rise and the risks of releasing new intellectual property (IP) increase, studios often turn to established franchises to ensure financial success. By reviving beloved games, developers can capitalize on nostalgia and attract players old and new.

However, this trend has also sparked debate about game creativity. Some critics argue that an over-reliance on remakes and remasters stifles innovation by diverting resources from developing new ideas. It is an ongoing challenge for developers to balance nostalgia and originality while meeting player expectations in a highly competitive market.

Conclusion

Ultimately, whether to choose a remake or a remaster comes down to gamer preference and what they’re looking for in a game. Both approaches offer unique opportunities to experience classic games in new ways. Remakes offer innovative reinterpretations that breathe new life into familiar stories, while remasters offer polished versions that retain the charm of the originals.

When considering which games are worth your time, consider your own gaming experience and history. Are you looking for a new interpretation of a classic, or do you prefer a comfortable dose of nostalgia? Whatever your preference, both remakes and remasters enrich the gaming experience and offer something for every type of player.